Ever had a YouTube video do way better than expected? The comments are rolling in, views are climbing, and you know this one has legs. But then comes the frustrating part – you want to repurpose it into Shorts, Reels, or TikToks so it keeps working for you everywhere… and you’re stuck.
Because clipping takes forever.
You’ve got to scan through 20, 30, maybe even 60 minutes of footage to find the best soundbites. Then you trim, resize for vertical, add captions, format it, export it… and that’s just for one short. Multiply that by the 10–15 clips you know you could make, and suddenly your “winning” video feels more like a workload.
This is where AI-powered shorts generators come in. Instead of wasting hours on manual clipping, tools like Klap and ClipGoat can automatically find highlights in your long videos and turn them into polished shorts, ready to publish, often within minutes.
The question is: which one’s better for you?
Klap is known for its clean, beginner-friendly workflow, while ClipGoat offers a feature-packed experience for creators who like more control. Both can save you hours. But depending on your style and budget, one might fit better than the other.
Let’s break it down.
This post may contain affiliate links. TrialBear earns commissions at no extra cost to you when purchases are made through links on this page. For more info, visit the disclosure page.
What are Klap and ClipGoat?
Both Klap and ClipGoat fall into the same category: AI-powered clip makers. These are tools built to help creators, marketers, and even small businesses take long-form videos and quickly repurpose them into short, viral-friendly content.
Klap
Think of Klap as the “plug-and-play” option. You paste in your YouTube link (or upload a file), and Klap’s AI instantly finds the best moments. It automatically reframes shots, adds captions, and spits out shorts that are practically ready to post.
If you’re new to editing or just want speed, Klap feels like an assistant who gets it right most of the time on the first try. You can always still use the built-in editor to make corrections if the tool doesn’t get it right on the first try.
Klap offers a 3-day free trial of its paid plans so you can get familiar with its clipping features.
ClipGoat
ClipGoat, on the other hand, is like the creative lab for short-form. Yes, it generates clips from long-form content, but it doesn’t stop there. You can use AI to generate hooks, titles, and hashtags. You can even turn Reddit posts into narrated videos or spin plain text into AI-narrated shorts. It’s built for creators who like experimenting with different formats and platforms.
Unlike Klap, there is no free trial of the paid plan. However, ClipGoat has a very good free plan that is free forever as long as you’re OK with the limitations.
Both tools save time. Both tools help you ride the short-form wave. But they approach the problem a little differently: Klap goes for simplicity and polish, while ClipGoat leans into flexibility and features.
Klap vs. ClipGoat: Ease of Use
Both Klap and ClipGoat are designed to be simple. You don’t need to be an editor to get results, and that’s the whole point. But the way you get started on each platform is slightly different.
Klap’s workflow is straightforward:
- Paste in a YouTube link or upload your video directly.
- Click generate and let the AI analyze.
- Within minutes, you’ll have a batch of clips ready.
- From there, you can edit them, download the clips you need or connect to the accounts where you want to post.
- Or you can schedule your clips to go live with Klap’s built-in calendar.
This process feels fast, clean, and flexible, especially since you’re not limited to YouTube videos. If you’ve got raw footage sitting on your computer, you can upload it and Klap will handle the rest.
ClipGoat’s process is also smooth, but with one catch: your content needs to already be on YouTube. You can paste a YouTube link or even a whole channel URL (and pick the video you want), then let the AI find the highlights.
Just like Klap, you can tweak the clips if needed, then download or schedule them for posting.
The only downside? Since ClipGoat doesn’t let you upload directly, you’ll have to publish your video on YouTube first before clipping it. That extra step might not be a big deal for YouTubers who upload everything anyway, but if you’re working with other content sources (say a Zoom recording, podcast, or webinar), Klap is the better option.
Klap vs. ClipGoat: AI Accuracy & Clip Quality
The magic of these tools is in how well the AI does the heavy lifting. You want clips that look professional without spending hours fixing them.
Klap’s editing power really shines here:
- Its AI Reframe 2 automatically picks the best layout for your content – split screen, gaming frames, or talking-head crops. No manual resizing needed.
- The built-in Virality Score points out which moments are most likely to pop off.
- Captions are impressively accurate and styled in a way that feels native to social platforms. And if something’s off, you can jump into the editor to adjust.
Because of this, Klap consistently produces clips that feel polished right out of the gate. It’s especially strong for podcasts, educational content, interviews, and speaking events – anything where clear delivery and clean formatting matter.
ClipGoat’s AI tools are solid but play a little differently:
- It also has a Virality Score that predicts which clips could perform best.
- Its clip detection works fine but sometimes feels less consistent in pacing, especially with talking-heavy videos.
- The real sweet spot for ClipGoat is action-packed content: gaming streams, sports highlights, live broadcasts. That’s where its AI tends to lock onto the energy and create exciting shorts.
Klap vs. ClipGoat: Subtitle & Caption Quality
Captions are huge for short-form videos. A lot of viewers, including myself, scroll with the sound off, so your subtitles need to be accurate, synced, and easy to read.
Klap’s captions stand out:
- Supports 52 languages, so your content isn’t limited to English-speaking audiences.
- The text syncs really well with speech – no awkward delays or mismatches.
- The styles look modern and clean, which makes the clips feel platform-native right away.
ClipGoat’s captions are solid too.
- Works best with English-language content, so it’s not as versatile for global reach.
- The captions are accurate in most cases, but don’t always match Klap’s level of polish.
- You do get some flexibility with customizable caption styles, which is handy if you want to experiment with different looks.
Klap vs. ClipGoat: Scheduling & Export Options
Getting clips is one thing, but getting them out on time (and in the right format) is what really saves creators hours each week.
Klap shines here:
- The Calendar feature lets you schedule and send clips directly to your YouTube Shorts, TikTok, LinkedIn or Instagram Reels.
- You can export in multiple formats, so whether you need vertical for TikTok or square for Instagram, you’re covered.
- If you manage multiple accounts, the scheduling feature makes it easy to keep a steady posting flow without juggling tools.
The process is as simple as connecting your social accounts and then selecting the clip you want to post in the calendar.
ClipGoat gives you some straightforward export options too. Select Content Publisher from the dashboard and you’re ready to go. Just connect an account and you’re ready.
- Export clips to the only two available options – YouTube Shorts or TikTok
- Content Publisher is not as advanced as Klap’s calendar setup. Think of it more as a “basic queue” compared to Klap’s more polished scheduling.
Klap vs. ClipGoat: Pricing & Free Options
When it comes to pricing, both tools take a slightly different approach.
Klap keeps it simple with three monthly plans:
- Klap Plan – $29/m
- Klap Pro Plan – $79/m
- Klap Pro+ Plan – $189/m
Annual plans are also available at a discounted rate.
There’s no permanent free plan, but you can test it out with a free trial before committing. That makes it easy to see the full power of the platform, but once the trial ends, you’ll need a subscription.
ClipGoat is a bit more flexible. The main plans are:
- Creator Plan – $20/m
- Pro Plan – $40/m
- Ultimate Plan – $80/m
And if you pay yearly you basically get three months free.
Here’s where it stands out: you don’t have to upgrade if you don’t want a subscription. Instead, you can buy credit packs starting as low as $5, which is perfect if you only need clips occasionally. On top of that, ClipGoat actually has a usable free plan, something Klap doesn’t offer.
Who Each Tool Is Best For
At this point, you can see both Klap and ClipGoat are strong contenders. The real question is: which one fits your style of content and workflow best?
Klap is best for you if:
- You create podcasts, interviews, educational videos, or talking-head content.
- You want a tool that feels more “set it and forget it”—just upload, let AI handle layouts, captions, and scoring, and walk away with polished clips.
- You’re serious about posting consistently and like the idea of built-in scheduling to multiple platforms.
- You don’t mind paying a subscription to get all the features in one place.
- You need to reach a wider global audience with multiple languages.
Or you can go with ClipGoat if:
- You focus on gaming content, live streams, sports, or fast-action videos where ClipGoat’s detection shines.
- You prefer to stick with YouTube as your content hub (since it pulls videos directly from there).
- You want a free plan that’s actually usable, or the flexibility to buy credit packs instead of paying monthly.
- You like more hands-on customization, especially with captions and clip styling.
ClipGoat also has a bunch of extras that are creator friendly. UGC Hook tool, Text to Speech tool, fake text message tool and the Reddit post to video tool looks fantastic too.
Klap leans more toward creators who want an efficient, pro-level workflow for repurposing long-form into viral shorts. ClipGoat is better if you’re budget-conscious, gaming-focused, or want flexibility without being tied to a subscription.
Final Verdict
Both Klap and ClipGoat solve the same problem: turning your long-form videos into short, viral-ready content without spending hours in an editor. But the way they go about it is slightly different.
Klap is like having a pro editor on autopilot. It’s polished, smart, and built for creators who want consistency and speed. The automatic reframing, accurate multilingual captions, and scheduling make it perfect if you’re running a channel that needs to post often.
ClipGoat is the scrappy, flexible option. The free plan is generous, the credit system gives you control over costs, and its clip detection works especially well with gaming and live-action content.
So who wins?
I really want to go with Klap here but personally, my content works better with ClipGoat. Honestly, Klap has the edge but not by much. Both tools work well for different needs.
If you’re a general YouTuber, podcaster, educator, or content marketer, I’d say start with Klap. The free trial lets you see just how much time it saves, and once you’re in the workflow, it’s hard to go back.
But if you’re a gamer or budget-focused creator who wants a tool that’s affordable and flexible, then ClipGoat is worth a shot. The free plan alone might be enough to get you rolling.
At the end of the day, both tools can help you post more, stress less, and give your best videos a second life in short form. The only question is: which one fits your style best?
